Boats for Sale in Bay Shore

23 Results

Relevance
Best

Filters

Price

$
to
$

Lower bound is greater than upper bound. Please adjust the range.

Loading histogram...

Condition

Length

ft.
to
ft.

Lower bound is greater than upper bound. Please adjust the range.

Loading histogram...

Manufacturers

Activity Type

Year

to

Lower bound is greater than upper bound. Please adjust the range.

Loading histogram...

Boat Features

Explore an extensive selection of boats for sale in Bay Shore, NY, nestled along the scenic Great South Bay. This prime location offers vibrant boating culture, perfect for enthusiasts who enjoy fishing, cruising, and watersports. Popular boat types in the area include sleek center consoles and versatile pontoon boats, ideal for navigating the bay’s calm waters. Whether you’re searching for new models or high-quality used boats, our listings provide a broad range tailored to your needs and budget. Don’t miss out—browse now and discover your perfect vessel to enjoy the stunning coastal lifestyle of Bay Shore. Nearby listings are also available to expand your options.

Currently, there are 23 boats available for sale in Bay Shore, New York. Prices range from $2,500 to $1,099,900, with an average listing price of $283,930. The inventory includes 3 new boats and 20 used boats. The selection consists of 22 powerboats and 1 sailboats. 4 boats have been added to the marketplace in the past month. Popular boat types include Center Console, Bowrider, Power Cruisers, Sport Fishing, and Walkaround. Top manufacturers represented include Viking, Formula, Monterey, Mainship, and Boston Whaler. There have been 60 boats in New York listed on MarineSource that have sold in the past year. October is the most common month for new and used boats to be added to MarineSource, so be sure to check back regularly. June is the most common month for boats to sell, so be sure to beat the rush! The most common activities for boats are day cruising, family fun, saltwater fishing, long distance cruising, and offshore fishing. Most boats in New York contain with heads, gps, with cabins, depth sounder, and heated interior. boats tend to have an average of 1 engine. It is common for boats to have Mercury engines or Yamaha engines or Mercruiser engines.

Insights and Analytics for Boats for Sale in Bay Shore, New York

Updated November 18, 2026

23
total boats for sale in Bay Shore, New York
4
boats for sale in Bay Shore, New York added in the past month
60
boats for sale in Bay Shore, New York sold in the past year
$283,930
is the average listing price of boats for sale in Bay Shore, New York

Condition

There are 3 new and 20 used boats for sale in Bay Shore, New York

Price

The most common price for boats for sale in Bay Shore, New York is $145k-$217k

Popular boat types

The most popular types of boats for sale in Bay Shore, New York are Center Console, Bowrider and Power Cruisers

Popular manufacturers

The most popular manufacturers of boats for sale in Bay Shore, New York are Viking, Formula and Monterey

Popular activities

The most popular activities for boats for sale in Bay Shore, New York are Day Cruising, Family Fun and Saltwater Fishing

Popular features

The most popular features for boats for sale in Bay Shore, New York are With Heads, GPS and With Cabins

Market Activity

The busiest month for boats for sale in Bay Shore, New York is Sep, with 3 boats added and 13 boats sold

Browse Boats by Condition in Bay Shore

Be the First to Know

Get notified when new boats become available.

Sign in

or
Login with Google

Check your inbox

We sent a magic link to your email address. Follow the magic link to finish signing in.