1999 Legacy 40
$125,000
$149,000
Boat in San Pedro, CA 90731 US
40
2 Engines (2x Cummins)
40 feet
Diesel
Fiberglass/Reinforced
"St. Elmo's Fire II" is a beautifully maintained Down East-style cruising yacht, cared for by knowledgeable owners since new. Built in Middletown, Rhode Island by Freedom Yachts and designed by the renowned Mark Ellis, the Legacy 40 is widely respected for her classic lines, exceptional craftsmanship, and proven sea-keeping ability.
Her traditional lobster-boat hull with round bilges and a full keel delivers a stable, comfortable ride while sipping fuel at cruising speed. Powered by twin Cummins 330s, she's both reliable and efficient-ideal for extended coastal cruising or weekends to Catalina.
The Herreshoff-inspired pilothouse and salon offer timeless elegance and superb visibility. The bridgedeck and cockpit are large and thoughtfully arranged, with excellent helm ergonomics and comfortable seating for guests. Despite the engines being located directly below the deck, careful insulation and sound baffling ensure remarkably quiet operation.
Below deck, the layout is bright and welcoming. To starboard, a generous L-shaped settee and convertible table make for comfortable dining or lounging. To port, a well-equipped galley features a large refrigerated icebox, three-burner stove with oven, and double stainless sinks. The head compartment offers dual access from both the salon and stateroom. Forward, a spacious queen sized berth provides for a good nights rest. There is abundant storage in drawers and hanging lockers.
Lovingly maintained and tastefully upgraded, "St. Elmo's Fire II" features a beautifully painted hull and all the gear needed for safe, enjoyable cruising. Her wide side decks and oversized cockpit make movement around the boat safe and easy, even underway. The airy salon and comfortable stateroom make her feel much larger than a typical 40-footer of this style.
For the discerning cruiser who values quality, heritage, and seaworthiness, St. Elmo's Fire II is a standout. A perfect Catalina cruiser and true classic that must be seen to be appreciated.
Hull, Deck & Construction
The Legacy 40 features a hand-laminated FRP hull, superstructure, deck, and liners with a balsa core. The hull-to-deck joint is a robust shoe-box type, fastened and sealed with 3M-5200. A molded FRP rub rail with a stainless half-round strip provides additional hull protection.
Highlights:
Aristo Blue Awlgrip hull finish
Stainless steel bow rail and handrails on cabin top
Bowmar hatches and opening ports
Cast stainless bow, spring, and stern cleats with chocks
Swim platform with stainless rail and swim ladder
Transom door with stay
Hot and cold transom shower
Raw-water washdown
Sunbrella bimini top
Stainless radar arch
Vertical-mounted 12V windlass
Galvanized anchor on bow roller
(3) Windshield wipers
Non-skid decks with bilge access hatch
Bennett trim tabs
Accommodations
The interior features teak cabinetry with a varnished teak-and-holly sole. The salon is light, airy, and beautifully finished in classic Herreshoff style, offering excellent natural light and ventilation. The Salon dinette converts into a queen berth, and the bridgedeck table and settee convert to a double. Bring your family and friends- she can sleep 6 comfortably!
Master Stateroom (Forward):
Island V-berth with ensuite head access
Cedar-lined hanging locker
Full-length locker with shelving
Overhead hatch and two opening portlights
Drawer and locker storage to port and starboard
Teak hull panels and trim
Reading and overhead lighting
Head:
VacuFlush marine toilet
TankWatch holding tank alert system
Separate stand up shower stall with curtain and handheld wand
Waste tank “Y” valve
Opening portlight
In-counter and medicine cabinet storage
Mirror and lighting
Salon:
Starboard L-shaped settee converts to a queen berth
Privacy curtain for use when the dinette is converted to a berth
Dinette table
Ample storage under settee
Overhead hatch and (2) opening portlights
Bose stereo speakers
Espar diesel heat and cruising water heater
120V AV water heater for dockside use
Overhead lighting with dimmers and reading lamps
Teak and holly sole
Entertainment center with teak doors
Flatscreen TV on swivel mount
Bose stereo and Onkyo DVD player
AC/DC electrical panel
Galley (Port Side):
U-shaped layout with Corian countertops
Double stainless sink with pull-out faucet
3-burner propane stove and oven
Adler Barbour plate refrigeration (front & top access)
Top-loading icebox and dry storage
GE microwave oven
Opening port for ventilation
Ample overhead and under-counter storage
Electrical & Mechanical Systems
Inverter
Fireboy engine-room fire suppression system
(2) 8D engine start batteries
(2) 8D house batteries
Independent 12V batteries per engine
Engine alternators
Glendinning engine synchronizer
Side-Power bow thruster
Reverso oil change system
(3) Bilge pumps with float switches & high-water alarms
Overboard discharge
Bridge Deck & Cockpit
Double-wide helm seat
Companion swivel seat with storage below
L-shaped lounge with table- Converts to a double berth
Aft-facing cockpit bench seat
Non-skid decks
Bose speakers
Transom door
(2) Folding deck chairs with cushions
EPIRB
Electronics & Navigation
Simrad AP22 autopilot
Simrad 10” EVO touchscreen MFD
Simrad GPS/Plotter
Furuno radar
Raytheon depth display
Raytheon speed display
Icom ICM-330 VHF radio
5" Ritchie compass
Remarks
“St. Elmo’s Fire II” exemplifies the timeless Legacy craftsmanship and Mark Ellis design — efficient, elegant, and capable. Her layout, systems, and finish quality make her an ideal coastal cruiser for those who appreciate Down East styling, rugged New England construction, and refined comfort.
West Coast Yachts offers the details of this vessel in good faith but cannot guarantee or warrant the accuracy of this information nor warrant the condition of the vessel. A buyer should instruct his agents, or his surveyors, to investigate such details as the buyer desires validated. This vessel is offered subject to prior sale, price change, or withdrawal without notice.
Price History
| Date | Event | Price |
|---|---|---|
| 4/1/26 | Price decreased | $125,000(-16.1%) |
| 1/17/26 | Price decreased | $149,000(-14.9%) |
| 10/16/25 | Initial price | $175,000 |
1999 Legacy 40 Video Tours
Overview from around the web 1999 Legacy 40
Customers praise the 1999 Legacy 40 for its solid construction and excellent sailing performance
Many highlight its spacious and well-designed interior, which provides comfort for extended trips. Owners appreciate the boat’s responsiveness and stability in various sea conditions, making it a reliable choice for both cruising and racing. The Legacy 40 is also noted for its quality craftsmanship and attention to detail, contributing to its enduring appeal among sailing enthusiasts. Overall, feedback emphasizes satisfaction with the boat’s blend of performance, comfort, and durability.
The Biggest Pros and Cons
The 1999 Legacy 40 is a well-regarded sailboat known for its blend of performance and comfort. Here are some pros and cons to consider:
Pros
Solid Construction: Built with quality materials and craftsmanship, ensuring durability and longevity.
Spacious Interior: Offers comfortable living quarters with ample headroom and well-designed cabins, making it ideal for extended cruising.
Good Sailing Performance: Balanced sail plan and hull design provide stable and responsive handling, suitable for both coastal and offshore sailing.
Versatile Layout: Practical layout with functional galley and navigation station, enhancing onboard livability.
Strong Community Support: Popular among cruising enthusiasts, making it easier to find parts and advice.
Cons
Older Design: Being a 1999 model, some design elements and onboard systems may feel dated compared to newer boats.
Maintenance Needs: As with any older vessel, it may require ongoing maintenance and occasional upgrades to keep systems current.
Limited Modern Electronics: Original navigation and onboard electronics might need updating to meet modern standards.
Weight: The boat may be heavier than newer designs, potentially affecting speed and fuel efficiency under power.
Made For
The 1999 Legacy 40 is designed for sailing enthusiasts who seek a versatile and comfortable cruiser. It is ideal for those who enjoy extended coastal voyages or weekend getaways, offering a blend of performance, spacious accommodations, and solid construction. Whether you are a seasoned sailor or a couple looking for a reliable and stylish sailing yacht, the Legacy 40 provides an excellent balance of handling and comfort for a variety of sailing adventures.
Finance your dream boat!
Finance your dream boat!
Be the first to know when similar boats hit the market
Get notified when new boats become available
Meet the Broker

Address
Boat Location
Contact West Coast Yachts about 1999 Legacy 40
2600 Newport Blvd., Suite 122, Newport Beach, CA, 92663
Contact West Coast Yachts
2600 Newport Blvd., Suite 122, Newport Beach, CA, 92663





















































































