2018 Godfrey Sweetwater 2286 FS
$21,435
Boat in Tuckerton, NJ 08087 US
Built in 2018
Sweetwater 2286 FS
1 Engine (Yamaha)
21 feet
Gas
Aluminum
2018 Sweetwater 2286 FS Premium Edition Tritoon | Yamaha F150 (258 hrs)
Built for cruising and light fishing - with the stability of a tritoon and the power to actually move
Quick Take
If you're looking for a pontoon that can handle both relaxed cruising and casual fishing without feeling underpowered, this one checks the right boxes.
With a tritoon setup and a Yamaha 150, it's a noticeable step up in ride quality and performance compared to standard pontoons in this range.
Who This Boat Is For
- Families or groups of 6-10 people
- Boaters splitting time between cruising, sandbars, and light fishing
- Anyone wanting more stability and a smoother ride than a traditional 2-tube pontoon
- Buyers looking for a solid used option without jumping into new pricing
Who This Is NOT For
- If you want a pure fishing platform with a full tournament setup
- If you're chasing high-speed performance or watersports-focused setups
- If you're expecting a flawless cosmetic condition, this is a used boat with noted wear
Why This Boat Over Others
- Tritoon package → noticeably better stability and ride in choppier water vs standard pontoons
- Yamaha F150 (approx. 258 hrs) → reliable, proven power with enough push for a full load
- Fishing + cruising layout → gives you flexibility without committing to one use
- Electronics already installed → Simrad GPS and Polk audio system ready to go
- Raised helm + high-back captain's chair → better visibility and comfort while running
What People Get Wrong About Boats Like This
Most buyers assume all pontoons ride the same.
They don't.
The tritoon setup here makes a real difference once you get into chop or load the boat with people-it tracks better, rides smoother, and feels more controlled overall.
Power & Performance Reality Check
- Engine: Yamaha F150 (approx. 258 hours)
- Best use: Balanced setup for cruising with enough power for tubing/light watersports
- Performance expectation: Strong mid-range power - not a speed boat, but won't feel sluggish under load
Features That Actually Matter
- Tritoon package → improved ride quality and stability
- Simrad GPS → navigation and depth awareness already handled
- Polk stereo system → solid sound setup without needing upgrades
- Ski tow bar → ready for tubing and light tow sports
- Fishing seats (2) → keeps it functional without sacrificing lounge space
- Raised helm → better sightlines while underway
Condition Notes (Transparent)
- Starboard midship rail has visible dent/damage
- Overall, this is a used boat and priced accordingly
If cosmetic perfection is your priority, this isn't your boat.
If you care more about function, layout, and value, it makes sense.
Value Positioning
This sits in a strong value spot for a tritoon with a 150hp motor.
You're getting the performance and versatility of a higher-tier setup without stepping into new-boat pricing.
Specs & Options
- Model: 2018 Sweetwater 2286 FS Premium Edition
- Configuration: Tritoon package
- Engine: Yamaha F150 (approx. 258 hours)
- Color: Blue panel / Grey rails
- Flooring: Harbor Beige
- Interior: Gray
- Helm: Raised helm with high-back captain's chair
- Seating: Includes 2 fishing chairs
- Electronics: Simrad GPS, Polk stereo system
- Tow: Ski tow bar
Straight Answer, No Runaround
Not sure if this is the right fit for how you boat?
Call or text us directly - we'll tell you honestly if this makes sense for you or if you should be looking at something else.
The Company offers the details of this vessel in good faith but cannot guarantee or warrant the accuracy of this information nor warrant the condition of the vessel. A buyer should instruct his agents, or his surveyors, to investigate such details as the buyer desires validated. This vessel is offered subject to prior sale, price change, or withdrawal without notice.
Price History
| Date | Event | Price |
|---|---|---|
| 4/11/26 | Initial price | $21,435 |
Videos from Sheltered Cove Marina on this 2018 Godfrey Sweetwater 2286 FS
2018 Godfrey Sweetwater 2286 FS Video Tours
Overview from around the web 2018 Godfrey Sweetwater 2286 FS
The 2018 Godfrey Sweetwater 2286 FS is receiving positive feedback from customers who appreciate its spacious and versatile design, well-suited for both relaxation and fun on the water
Many users highlight the comfortable seating arrangement, which accommodates families and friends effortlessly, making it an excellent choice for gatherings. Customers often mention the boat's smooth handling and stability, even in varying water conditions, providing peace of mind during their outings. The powerful performance of the outboard motor is frequently praised, ensuring a thrilling yet reliable ride. In addition, owners frequently express satisfaction with the quality of materials used in the build, emphasizing durability and easy maintenance. The stylish design and customizable features are also noted as appealing aspects, allowing for a personalized touch that enhances the boating experience. Overall, feedback demonstrates that the 2018 Godfrey Sweetwater 2286 FS effectively combines comfort, performance, and quality, making it a popular choice among boating enthusiasts.
The Biggest Pros and Cons
Pros
Spacious Design: The Sweetwater 2286 FS offers ample room for family and friends, making it an ideal choice for gatherings on the water. Its layout encourages social interaction with plenty of seating.
Comfort Features: The boat is equipped with comfortable furniture, including plush seating and storage compartments that enhance the overall experience on the water.
Performance: With a robust engine capacity and efficient hull design, the Sweetwater 2286 FS delivers a smooth ride and responsive handling, suitable for both leisurely outings and more adventurous water activities.
Customization Options: Buyers can choose from a variety of colors, finishes, and additional features to tailor the boat to their unique preferences, allowing for a personalized touch.
Versatility: This pontoon is designed for a range of activities, from cruising to fishing, making it a versatile option for different water sports and leisure activities.
Quality Construction: Godfrey is known for its high-quality craftsmanship, and the Sweetwater series showcases durable materials and design that stand up to the demands of water use.
Cons
Price Point: As a premium product, the Sweetwater 2286 FS may come with a higher price tag compared to entry-level pontoons, which could be a consideration for budget-conscious buyers.
Weight: The size and construction can make the Sweetwater 2286 FS heavier than some smaller boats, potentially impacting towing and maneuverability in certain situations.
Maintenance Requirements: Like all boats, the Sweetwater 2286 FS will require regular maintenance and care, which can involve time and expenses.
Storage Needs: Due to its size, finding appropriate storage on land when the boat is not in use can be challenging, especially for those with limited space.
Limited Top Speed: While the Sweetwater 2286 FS offers great performance for cruising, it may not achieve the same top speeds as more performance-oriented boats, which might be a downside for those seeking high-speed thrills.
Made For
The 2018 Godfrey Sweetwater 2286 FS is designed for families and groups looking to elevate their on-water experiences. Ideal for leisurely days spent cruising with friends, fishing excursions, or simply soaking up the sun, this versatile pontoon boat is perfect for those who value comfort and style. Its spacious layout accommodates a sizable crowd, making it a great choice for social gatherings or family outings. With an emphasis on fun and relaxation, the Sweetwater 2286 FS caters to both thrill-seekers and those who prefer a more laid-back boating lifestyle. Whether you’re navigating calm lakes or exploring coastal waters, this pontoon delivers a smooth ride and unforgettable memories on the water.
Be the first to know when similar boats hit the market
Get notified when new boats become available
Boats For Sale in New Jersey, United States Similar to the 2018 Godfrey Sweetwater 2286 FS
Compare with similar boats and find the perfect one for you.
 2018 Godfrey Sweetwater 2286 FS | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $21,435 | $17,999 | $27,900 | $28,900 | $29,900 | $29,900 |
| Tuckerton | Lake Hopatcong | Lake Hopatcong | Toms River | Barnegat | Barnegat |
| 21' | 22' | 20' | 25' | 20' | 20' |
| Yamaha | - | - | Yamaha | yamaha | yamaha |
| 150 hp | - | - | 150 hp | 90 hp | 90 hp |
| 37 | 19 | 260 | 340 | 270 | 270 |
Other Godfrey boats for sale in New Jersey, United States
Meet the Broker
Address
Boat Location
Contact Sheltered Cove Marina about 2018 Godfrey Sweetwater 2286 FS
910 S Green St, Tuckerton, NJ, 08087
Login with Google